8 Signs You Didn’t Get the Apartment

Picture of Raymond Jenkins

Raymond Jenkins

signs you didn't get the apartment

Table of Contents

Navigating the world of apartment hunting can often feel like learning a new language. With the numerous rental applications, viewings, and discussions with landlords, it’s easy to lose sight of the finish line: getting approved for your dream apartment. 


However, the process isn’t always as smooth as we’d like, and rejections, though disheartening, are an inevitable part of this journey.


Understanding the signs that point towards a likely rejection can help you manage expectations and plan your next steps with greater precision.


One clear sign that you may not have cut is the submission of inaccurate paystubs. Yes, those little documents hold more power than you might think. 


An automatic denial often looms when your submitted paystubs contain errors, a suspicious design, or misalignments. 


These seemingly minor discrepancies can cast a shadow on your application, regardless of how well the rest of the process seems to have gone.


In this article, we will delve into eight signs that indicate you didn’t get the apartment, saving you from prolonged uncertainty and helping you realign your efforts in the right direction. 


These signs are from industry standards, rental patterns, and the collective experiences of numerous apartment hunters. 


So, let’s decode these signs and turn them into valuable insights for your future applications.


1. No Follow-Up After Application


In today’s digital age, communication has become almost instantaneous. This speed extends to the rental market as well, where a landlord or property manager’s prompt response often signals their interest in a potential tenant. 


If you’ve submitted your rental application and the follow-up from the other side is noticeably absent or significantly delayed, it might be the first sign that you still need to get the apartment.


A quick response, typically within 48 hours of application submission, usually indicates that your application has caught the landlord’s eye and they’re interested in discussing things further. 


In fact, according to real estate platform Zillow, a whopping 67% of successful applicants receive a follow-up within this timeframe.


A delayed response or no response at all can hint at the landlord’s disinterest or that they might be considering other applicants.


This lack of communication is often a red flag, hinting that your application might have yet to make the shortlist.


Don’t let this discourage you, though. Use it as a signal to keep your options open and continue your search elsewhere.


2. Absence of Verification Checks


When you forward a rental application, it’s standard for landlords or property management firms to execute in-depth verification checks.


This procedure is pivotal in the rental application review. It allows them to verify essential details, like whether you meet the stipulated income requirements.


If no one has called your employer or performed such checks after your application, it’s a significant hint that you might not get the apartment. These verification checks don’t only confirm the data you’ve given. They also shine a light on your financial stability and reliability.


For landlords, contacting your employer is a vital step in ensuring you’re financially equipped for the lease. 


They want to know if you can consistently pay rent and if your income aligns with their criteria.


Usually, if a landlord is keen on having you as a tenant, they’ll carry out these checks as part of their vetting process.


 If this doesn’t happen, it could suggest they’re leaning towards another applicant or there’s a concern with a different section of your application.


While it’s disappointing to recognize this hint, remember that it’s a single facet of your application. Use it as a cue to realign your efforts toward other potential apartments in your search.


3. Your Paystubs Raise Questions & Red Flags


One of the most critical components of your rental application is your pay stubs.


These documents serve as tangible proof of your income, showcasing your financial stability and ability to consistently cover rent. 


When your submitted paystubs raise questions due to inaccuracies, suspicious design, or misalignments, it can create a significant hurdle in your journey toward securing the apartment.


Landlords and property managers are well-versed in assessing paystubs. They know what legitimate documents look like and how to spot red flags. 


If they encounter discrepancies, such as incorrect information or unprofessional design, it’s almost certain to raise doubts about your application.


Submitting paystubs that accurately reflect your income and employment is crucial. If a landlord suspects that your paystubs might be fake, it can lead to an automatic denial. 


This suspicion doesn’t just question your ability to pay rent, but also your honesty and reliability as a potential tenant.


Therefore, it’s essential to ensure your paystubs are accurate and professionally presented. 


If you’re self-employed or have an unconventional income source, consider seeking advice on how best to present your financial information to avoid unintentional red flags.


Remember, getting an apartment is not just about demonstrating financial capability, but also about building trust with your potential landlord. Accurate, well-presented paystubs play a significant role in this endeavor.


4. The Apartment Listing Is Still Active


In our internet-centric era, online listings on platforms like Apartments.com have become the go-to source for apartment hunters. 


Landlords and property managers rely heavily on these platforms to advertise their properties and attract potential tenants. 


Hence, the status of the active listing can often provide important clues about your application’s status.


When a landlord or property manager has found a suitable tenant, one of the first things they’ll do is remove the online listing or mark it as rent. 


Their goal is to attract and screen potential tenants – a mission that’s accomplished once they’ve identified the right person. 


Keeping the listing active after this point serves no purpose for them and can lead to unnecessary inquiries.


So, if you notice that the listing is still active a few days after your interview, it could be a sign that they’re still looking. It might indicate that they’re not entirely convinced about your fit as a potential tenant or that they’re exploring other applications.


While this isn’t a definitive sign of rejection (after all, the landlord might just be slow to update the listing), it’s a hint that you should keep your options open. 


Continue exploring other listings and don’t halt your apartment hunt based on a single application. In the fluctuating rental market, staying proactive is key.


5. You’re Not Asked for Additional Documents


During the apartment rental process, being asked for additional documentation is generally a good sign. 


It suggests that the landlord or property manager is interested in your application and is taking steps to further verify the information you’ve provided. 


If they don’t request more documentation after you’ve submitted your application, it might be a subtle sign that you didn’t get the apartment.


Additional documentation can range from bank statements to the contact information of your previous landlord for rental verification. 


These documents provide a more comprehensive picture of your financial health and rental history. They indicate your financial stability, your employment security, and your track record as a tenant.


If your prospective landlord doesn’t ask for these, it could mean that they might not be seriously considering your application.


It’s possible that they’ve found a more promising applicant or noticed a deal-breaker in your application.


While it can be disappointing to interpret this as a negative sign, it’s important to remember that this isn’t a personal rejection. 


Different landlords have different criteria for their ideal tenants. Use this as a learning experience to fine-tune your application for future submissions and continue your search with optimism.


6. No Invitation For a Second Viewing


The process of securing an apartment often involves multiple viewings. 


The first viewing is typically a preliminary walkthrough, allowing potential tenants to get a feel for the space and decide if it aligns with their needs. 


If you’ve made a good impression and your application is being seriously considered, you’ll usually be invited for a second viewing. 


This is a more detailed look at the property where you can ask specific questions and maybe even discuss terms. 


If you’re not invited back for this second viewing, it could be a hint that you didn’t get the apartment.


A second viewing is not just beneficial for the potential tenant but also the landlord or property manager. 


It gives them a chance to gauge your seriousness about the property and to further assess if you’d be a good fit. 


The absence of a second viewing invitation could be due to various reasons such as:

  • Application Strength: There might be other applicants with stronger credentials, such as a higher income, longer rental history, or better credit score.


  • Immediate Decision: The landlord or management company may have made an immediate decision about a previous viewer, reducing the need for further viewings.


  • Limited Availability: Sometimes, the number of slots for viewings might be limited due to the landlord’s schedule or property management protocols.


  • Property Off the Market: The property could have been taken off the market temporarily or permanently for reasons such as maintenance, renovation, or a change in the landlord’s plans.


  • Communication Mishap: There might have been a communication error, and your contact details were misplaced or not recorded properly.


  • Preference for Virtual Tours: Due to various reasons, including efficiency or ongoing health concerns, the landlord may have switched to virtual viewings instead of in-person visits.


  • Feedback from Initial Viewing: Something during the first viewing, such as comments or questions you made, might have given the landlord reservations about proceeding further.


Remember, while missing a second viewing can be disappointing, it’s always a good idea to follow up with the landlord or agency to gain clarity on the situation.


7. Landlord Is Discreet About Move-In Dates


When a landlord is confident they’ve found the right tenant, they’re usually quick to discuss concrete move-in dates. 


This helps both parties plan and ensures a smooth transition.


However, if you find that the landlord is vague or non-committal when the topic of move-in dates arises, it may be a sign that you didn’t get the apartment.


The discussion of move-in dates indicates that the landlord is ready to welcome you into the property and start the contract.


This reluctance to give you a move-in date could be due to various reasons such as:


  • Other Promising Candidates: The landlord might be considering other applicants who, in their view, seem equally or more fitting for the property.


  • Evaluating Your Fit: The landlord may still be in the process of thoroughly reviewing your application and credentials before making a final decision.


  • Pending Paperwork: There could be some pending paperwork or verifications on their end which need to be sorted out first.


  • Current Tenant Delays: The present tenant might have requested an extension on their move-out date or haven’t yet finalized their moving plans.


  • Lease Agreement Terms: The landlord might still be finalizing the terms of the lease and isn’t ready to commit to a specific move-in date.


  • Market Considerations: Sometimes, landlords wait to see if the rental market conditions change in the short term, influencing their decisions on rent rates or lease terms.


Always communicate openly with potential landlords to get insights into any delays or uncertainties. This helps in setting the right expectations for both parties.


8.  AI Software Rejections: The Imperfect Gatekeeper


In today’s digital age, the rise of AI software in rental applications has become increasingly prevalent.


Platforms like Snappt are being used to detect fraudulent paystubs, aiming to streamline the rental application process for landlords.


A few points of consideration:

  • Accuracy Concerns: While these tools are advanced, they’re not infallible. AI software might sometimes inaccurately flag legitimate paystubs as fraudulent, especially if they’re generated using standard online paystub makers.



  • Dependence on Generators: Many employers, especially smaller companies, rely on online paystub generators for efficiency and cost-effectiveness. It’s unjust for a potential tenant to be penalized due to the tools their employer uses.


  • Human Touch Is Essential: Automated tools can offer speed and consistency, but the human element is crucial for nuanced decisions. There’s a rising concern that over-reliance on AI might miss out on genuine applicants who are an excellent fit for the property but got flagged due to minor technicalities.


For those faced with an AI-based rejection, it’s advisable to discuss the situation with the landlord, providing additional verification if needed.

Technology should facilitate, not hinder, the rental process.


Final Thoughts


Apartment hunting is a complex journey filled with anticipation and sometimes, disappointment. 


While securing your dream space, several subtle signs might hint at a less favorable outcome. 


These range from a lack of communication post-application to the absence of verification checks and unresolved questions about paystubs. 


In our digital age, even AI detection software, designed to streamline processes can sometimes misidentify legitimate documentation, underscoring the importance of the human touch in the decision-making process. 


Recognizing these signs not only helps in managing expectations but also in strategizing and refining future applications.


Though rejections can be disheartening, they should be viewed as opportunities to learn, adapt, and continue the search with renewed focus and optimism.


Thank you for taking the time to read this article. I sincerely hope it provided clarity and answers to your questions. Best of luck on your apartment-hunting journey!




What is one red flag when looking for an apartment?

If basic features and information about the apartment seem vague or don’t quite make sense, be cautious. It could be because the person who posted the property has never been there to accurately describe the space. Omitting details on utilities, square footage, property taxes, or the exact address is a major red flag.


How do you guarantee you will get the apartment?

  • Offer to sign a longer lease term. 
  • Make sure you pass all of your background checks. 
  • Get in the door first. 
  • Have your documents ready. 
  • Be mindful of your budget. 
  • Be courteous.


Can you ask why you were denied an apartment?

However, an individual property manager cannot deny you for any reasons that violate federal fair housing laws (FHA), such as your race or gender. The property manager may inform you about the reasons for your application’s denial. If not, you can request the reason politely.


What are the red flags to landlords?

Red Flag #1: Tenant Doesn’t Have Sufficient Income

After all, if your potential tenant doesn’t come home with a reasonable monthly paycheck, how will they be able to make their monthly payments? Check if they can continually afford the rent and any additional fees.


What not to say to a landlord?

What not to say to a landlord?

  • ‘I hate my current landlord’ Every potential landlord is going to ask why you’re moving. 
  • ‘I can’t wait to get a puppy’ …
  • ‘My partner works right up the street’ 
  • ‘I move all the time’


How do you improve your chances of renting?

Follow these rules!

  • Prepare your paperwork. Having your ducks in a row—and paperwork squared away—will make you stand out as a responsible and trustworthy tenant. 
  • Have a good credit history.
  • Have your money ready.
  • Sweeten the pot. 
  • Show how much you care about the property.
  • Move fast.


What to save for when getting an apartment?

Here’s a list of all the upfront costs and expenses your apartment savings fund should include and cover:

  • First month’s rent and last month’s rent. …
  • Security deposit. 
  • Application fees. 
  • Utilities.
  • Appliances, furniture, and apartment furnishings.
  • Insurance and additional fees. 
  • Moving costs. 
  • Miscellaneous costs.


Why apartment applications ask for your checking account number?

Apartment managers and landlords use your banking details to verify your income and the validity of your account. Having your details on hand just simplifies the process. Landlords and property managers may also request bank account details to set up automatic payments online.


Why was I rejected from apartment?

They are looking for information on whether you paid rent on time, if you damaged or maintained the property, and if you ever caused any problems in general. If your past landlord give less than stellar references, there is a chance you will get your rental application denied.


What questions Cannot be asked on a rental application?

  1. Do You Have A Service Animal? 
  2. How Many Kids Do You Have? 
  3. Do You Have Any Arrests? 
  4. So, When’s The Big Day? 
  5. Will You Be Retiring Soon? 
  6. What is your sex and sexual orientation? 
  7. What is your race? 
  8. What is your nationality?


What is credit screening?

The credit screening will reveal information like name, addresses (past and present), spouse’s name, date of birth, employers (past and present), and social security numbers. This is a great way for the person pulling the report to see if the person really is who he or she says they are. Take note of any red flags.

Latest blog & articles

Celebrate Christmas with Special Payroll Solutions from Paystub Hero!

To get 15% off this season

Wait, Don't Go Yet!

You are leaving too soon

To get 10% off on your first purchase